An
unspoken question looms about the future of the hockey equipment
industry. Are the manufacturers or the retailers profitable? The
situation is not good for either, as both the manufacturers and the big
retailers are currently hemorrhaging money!
The
biggest manufacturer, Bauer, has a 62% share of the market. They make
great product and they are publicly traded. Even though they own the
market, their profit is miniscule.
They are trying to add other categories to make their business model work,
but at this moment they probably have a break-even business even with their monster share.
Easton,
Reebok/CCM, Warrior and Sherwood have very little market share. They
have no chance of long-term success unless they come up with a way to
take market share from Bauer.
I
believe Sherwood/TPS will be the first to go under. They have almost
no share of the US market and their wood stick business is failing.
Reebok/CCM would be next. Poorly managed, they have failed miserably
every single year since the Reebok takeover of CCM. Adidas, which owns
Reebok, will decide if enough is enough this year. $20M to $40M of
losses (my estimate) year in and year out is not healthy, and there is
no end in sight. Their management team is horrendous and almost every
decision they make is puzzling. I believe it will become a house brand
for some big national retail store in Canada in the future.
Easton, as well is doing poorly. Their parent company, Bell Sports, is trying to sell the
hockey brand, though most interested parties want Easton's healthy baseball division as part of the package.
Warrior, owned by New Balance, is not big and will probably look at buying someone to increase share.
So,
after Bauer, which brands will fill out the top five? In this economy,
most hockey consumers stopped paying retail prices
for goods. On their present margins, the big manufacturers are not
currently profitable, so how will they reduce their prices?
Retailers
have been using manufacturer's credit in the $10s of millions of
dollars, but have been unable to pay them back for years. Do healthy US
businesses allow this in any other industry? The big retailers are
suffering a slow death. They are selling product at their cost in order
to raise cash so they can meet payroll, rent, etc. but usually have
very little left to pay the manufacturers. On the other hand, the
manufacturers are addicted to the 4 or 5 big retailers in the US as far
as loading them up with product, even though they pay them back very
slowly. These retailers are losing millions of dollars every year
and their only way out so far has been to not pay the manufacturers.
Let's
go back to my initial question. What are the brands of the future?
Once the manufacturers or their parent companies decide that they do not
wish to keep losing millions of dollars each year, they will start
calling the debts of the big retailers. Since those retailers do not
have the money, the manufacturers will probably take drastic action
(closing them down). I have asked my accounting buddies on my hockey
team if it is possible for a retailer to do $40M in sales and
have an
inventory of $40M and still be profitable. Their answer was
unanimous: NO WAY! But the manufacturers, with their actions, have
alienated all the smaller to mid-sized stores and have caused many of
them to shut down over the last few years. What will they do about the
consumer's trends (caused by the big retailers) to only buy heavily
discounted product?
These are questions that will be answered in 2013.
The
Tron business has grown ten-fold
since last year. We plan on continuing to grow by manufacturing great
product (in the same factories the big guys make it in) and selling it
at closeout prices. Our hockey visors, hockey jerseys, socks, gloves, inline
equipment all rank in the top five in sales. We will be able to
maintain our prices because we do not have the overhead the other
retailers or manufacturers have. We have pro players playing with our
hockey sticks and love them. Last year, we sold more visors than anyone other
than Bauer. We are currently selling more jerseys (also customized) and socks than anyone
due to the great quality and price. We are developing new products to
continue this trend of excellence. Keep your eyes on our website to see
what else we have to come!